I was in a high end grocery store after church today and wandered by the Beef Aisle. Left to right: Ribeye Steak for $28.99/lb, New York Steak for $24.99/lb and Tri-Tip for $18.99/lb. The ground beef (not shown) was $8.99/lb.
When you buy these items you have no idea of how many cows contributed the steaks and where they were from, how old (or young) they were, how they were treated. For the ground beef, you don't even know how many animals "contributed" to the product. In a word, it's all Mystery Meat of one variety or another.
If you buy from the Ranch, you get your Beef from one single animal, and you interact with your Butcher who cuts it to order. Not many people these days have clothing made to order by a tailor or dress-maker, or hire an architect to build a house just so; this might be your last chance to get something "to order." (And you can do it every year!) Bespoke Beef.
Let's say you buy a quarter beef and get 100 lbs of packages. You will pay, all-in, about $500. Call it $5.00/lb. You will get 30 lbs of steaks, 20 lbs of roasts, and about 50 lbs of ground beef, stew meat and well-fleshed soup bones. Enough for a family of four for 6 months to a year.
If you spend $500 on the grocery store's mystery meat, by the time you get 20 lbs of steaks at $25/lb, you will have spent the entire $500. Just 10 steak dinners. So: spend $500 for 10 mystery steaks, or spend $500 and get 30 steaks, 10 roasts and 50 packages of ground beef. As someone once said in a movie, "Help me help you."